Welcome!

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our community.

SignUp Now!
  • PLEASE PAY ATTTENTION

    Before making complaint with a prefix for curator of the project please read these rules.
    1. Make complaint only in case if you already posted for high admins and they did not help you.
    2. Complaints for curator of the project ONLY for management level complaints. You can't appeal your warning or 7 days ban. You can appeal only permanent or long-term bans.

    Thank you for attention! (c) Mazhor Pluxury
Rejected
Status
Not open for further replies.
Your ID
124198
Players nickname
Kiz Wolfpack
Administrators nickname
Saturo Anonymous
Date
Nov 10, 2025
Time
22:55
Proofs
https://gta5grand.com/forum/threads/1179435/

PukkaCheeZee

Player
Player
Joined
Feb 27, 2022
Messages
242
Dear Jonny Odds. I'm not sating I broke rules because someone else did.

I'm saying that within the Los Santos we are permitted to defend our spouse/family when under attack with lethal force. Now I'm also saying how is it GR6.15 if there was an RP situation of someone trying to kill my family ? And if this isn't an RP situation, can you please explain what is because it's confusing and never made clear by any admin asked. Which is detrimental to the play and quality of life in the city if we get punished for reacting within IC laws but get punished without clearly knowing what you guys say is and isn't an RP situation. Thank you again for your understanding and time.

I'd like to start of by saying that the admin reviewing I believe has made a mistake. I am punished for giving no demands given there is already an RP situation in where my family member has been shot at. I'd also like to point out the shooter initiated this RP situation by shooting my family member, WITHOUT DEMANDS! All I have done in reacted to the defense of my family member being attacked which is an RP situation!

I'd also like to ask as it's becoming increasingly unclear what is actually classed as an RP Situation then ?!


As seen in the original post. The poster of my report shoots at my family member because he has a bounty on him. (This initiates an RP situation where my family member is under attack with imminent threat of death to my family member, and as per the firearms laws of Los Santos, specifically; 5.2 Mutual or reciprocal defense is a type of defense that includes the protection of one's spouse, family member or co-worker under imminent threat of injury or death.

I then have opened fire to defend my family member who was already injured and moments from death. In a life threatening situation like this time is of the escence and I reacted appropriately with lethal force to defend my family as the law of San Andreas permits.

As per all this I don't see why I was punished for GR6.15 when the shooter had opened fire initiating this RP situation and also didn't even give demands to my family member who he was here to kill.

Thank you for taking the time to review this punishment.
Select for moderation
 

Jonny Odds

Deputy Chief Administrator
Deputy Chief Administrator
Joined
Dec 7, 2022
Messages
13,325
Rejected

I'm saying that within the Los Santos we are permitted to defend our spouse/family when under attack with lethal force.
No. IC Laws and OOC Rules have nothing to do with eachother. IC Laws only apply when OOC Rules are meet.

You received full answer here:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom