Rejected Unban Appeal | Ercan_Can

[Willow Blossom]

I was punished for GR 6.17 which specifies "It is forbidden to use OBS and any similar softwares for recordings. All overlays must be recorded."

In the POV video shown in thread Reviewed - RDM 174139 + 283449 it shows me using Medal.tv (clip and recording software). The reasoning Ercan told me for my punishment was because I was using Medal.tv which he didn't know what it was. Medal.tv doesnt share your screen and only your game (which is also something that you can do with Geforce Experience, which is considered allowed on the server, view image below for geforce experience).

https://imgur.com/NMNzLTm

So if medal.tv isn't allowed due to not capturing your whole screen, geforce experience shouldnt either as it is toggleable. If it's mentioned that the geforce experience one is toggleable, it doesn't specify in GR 6.17 that you have to capture your whole screen. Simply says that you cant use OBS or any similar software, but not the reason that OBS isnt allowed.

 

[Willow Blossom]

In addition, I would like to mention that Geforce Experience has desktop capture off by default. This means that the player will have to go into the settings, go down to privacy control at the bottom, and then enable desktop capture

 

[Willow Blossom]

I would also like to mention that medal has also been mentioned in the discord server hundreds of times and hundreds of players use it as an alternative to Geforce experience.

 

[Ercan Can]

https://imgur.com/a/MQ3jSuP

The rule is pretty clear: 6.17 It is forbidden to use OBS and any similar softwares for recordings. All overlays must be recorded.

 

[Willow Blossom]

The rule specifies we shouldn't use OBS or similar softwares yes but it doesn't specify the reasoning that we can't use OBS. I only found out after I was punished that it was because it didn't capture my whole screen. Not to mention, if so many users still use medal then why don't you make a list of allowed and disallowed recording softwares so things like this don't happen? "OBS or similar software" seems very broad and unspecific

 

[Willow Blossom]

All overlays must be recording doesn't really intend to mean that you must capture your whole screen

 

[Willow Blossom]

And please don't make the same thing that happened with my past complaint to happen here where only one of my points were read and all the others were ignored.

 

[Alex Odd]

Fair decision by admin
Rules clearly describes WHAT must be recorded on POVs and what soft should be used and what not
closed