As already explained in the thread, it seems like you dont show the interaction from the start (as also indicated by the other pov), which lets me think you cutted out something on purpose.
From the POV shown by them, you are violating GR3.1+3.2 while in your Post you claim "We both didn't say a word to them before".
I would consider this as purposefully deceiving admins by cutting pov. Instead of issuing that against you I wanted to give you the benefit of the doubt, rejected it and thus gave you the opportunity to reupload the full Situation and explain your point. This was not an Event-POV request.
I dont know anyone in the pov (at least not to my Knowledge) so its not a biased decision.
Just reupload the whole interaction in another thread and it will get reviewed by another admin. I dont understand the point of this complaint.