Hello Admins
The scenario involved a suspect armed with a revolver and a hostage. I would like to explain that at the time of cuffing, the hostage was not being threatened, held, or aimed at, and additional law enforcement officers were more in numbers. The suspect had already left the hostage running. Cuffing the suspect in this context was a realistic and procedurally sound law enforcement action, not Fail RP, as there was no immediate threat to life. How does this qualify as Fail RP when the hostage was not in danger? Actions like this should not be penalized, as punishing spoils the roleplay experience.
Furthermore, Mr. Carlos Bloofield had previously approved the same thread under FAIL RP + PG for this situation, but later edited it and removed PG—perhaps after determining it was not PG, which occurred only after approving the thread. This suggests that the POV was not properly verified and fails to recognize that cuffing a person holding a single revolver is not PG. Such inconsistency undermines trust in admins and creates confusion among players, as some consider the action correct while others do not. In the End Spoils Role Play
Thanks
Simba
Approved - Fail RP + PG | 83281
He cuffed the Person instantly who was holding the hostage. The hostage was just in front of him and was not safe at all. 83281 abused his Cuffs and gave no chance to the person to react or get in the car.
gta5grand.com
Furthermore, Mr. Carlos Bloofield had previously approved the same thread under FAIL RP + PG for this situation, but later edited it and removed PG—perhaps after determining it was not PG, which occurred only after approving the thread. This suggests that the POV was not properly verified and fails to recognize that cuffing a person holding a single revolver is not PG. Such inconsistency undermines trust in admins and creates confusion among players, as some consider the action correct while others do not. In the End Spoils Role Play
Thanks
Simba
