Rejected Wrong Decision | Ishaan_DaFirenze

[Mirhan Sahin]

As shown in the evidence I provided, I noticed that a player's items were listed with different unit prices. I called Administrator Ishaan and Administrator Rezwan to review the situation. After checking the market, they stated that it was simply a discount and that, because the prices were relatively close to each other, it could not be considered a scam.

However, I will now provide a video in which a player was banned for listing batteries with only a $2,500 price difference between them

. This raises an important question: what if that player obtained one battery for free through the Battle Pass and acquired the other by installing solar panels, then decided to maintain the same profit margin by listing them at different prices? Or perhaps the player intentionally listed one at a lower price so that someone could benefit from the cheaper option. Regardless of the reason, it is clear from the punishment issued in that case that the server rules do not allow different unit prices for identical items and that such behavior is considered a scam.

For this reason, I believe this player should also be punished for violating G.R 1.3, as they clearly listed identical items with different unit prices.

In addition, approximately 15 minutes before this incident, I witnessed another player being banned for listing 74 mushrooms at a unit price of $1,475 while listing 9 mushrooms at a unit price of $1,500. Given these previous punishments, I respectfully request that my report be reviewed and that the player in question receive the appropriate punishment in order to ensure consistency in rule enforcement.

 

[Adham Pluxury]

Player got punished already for violating general rule 1.3.​