I would also like to say that Proper FearRP should not only consider the one person's life. You are asking an officer to drop a local to call his department into a setup/ambush. His refusal to do so makes perfect sense because he has proper FearRP for other lives as well. I would much rather die in the line of duty than be the reason for the deaths of my fellow officers. Without proper audio theres no way to hear what was said. Furthermore he did comply to some of the demands as you see him uncuffing the suspect when commanded to.
Its obvious to me that you are playing favorites and the one lying and abusing your power as an admin. You claim he didnt listen to any demands when the video without audio even shows that he complied to some of them otherwise he wouldn't have uncuffed the suspect. The admins POV should be requested as well as the players involved and punishment should be given for all rules broken by all parties involved, not just the LSPD officer.