The evidence of continued harassment was given. Favoritism of the offending player is obvious. In doing so, continued spread of discrimination against those identifying as homosexual is also obvious. If this is not fact, then the administrator "Big Dave" does not know how to do their admin duties, and should be returned to a probationary state to learn how to fulfill their duties as admin. The reason to return the mentioned administrator to a probationary state, is if "insufficient evidence" is true, then you ask for more evidence, you do not close the thread. Closing the thread is proof in itself as favoritism of the offending player.